On this theoretical article, I critically present the ongoing debate on the relationship between globalization, poverty and inequality. To do so, I rely on the typology put forward by Held & McGrew (2007), which divides scholars between two main approaches: the globalists and the skeptics. Among the first approach, one can then distinguish between neoliberal globalists and transformationalist globalists. Among the second one, one can distinguish between realist skeptics and Marxist skeptics. I go through the most important thinkers of each of these four perspectives, summing up the most influential arguments put forward to support their view. By grouping the views of these scholars, I show similarities and differences between the four perspectives and thus contribute to making the debate more clear. In a further section, I critically assess these arguments, identifying some of their strengths and shortcomings.
THE DEBATE ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN GLOBALIZATION, POVERTY AND INEQUALITY: A CRITICAL OVERVIEW
»
vicentedinisvalentim@gmail.com
Master's degree in Political Science (ISCTE, Portugal). Degree in Piano Jazz by the School of Music in Lisbon, Lisbon Polytechnic Institute. He concluded Minor in Political Science at the Faculty of Social and Human Sciences, New University of Lisbon.
Resumo
Neste artigo teórico, apresento de forma crítica o debate em curso sobre a relação entre globalização, pobreza e desigualdade, recorrendo à tipologia proposta por Held & McGrew (2007), que divide os autores em duas abordagens principais: os globalistas e os céticos. Na primeira abordagem, podemos fazer a distinção entre globalistas neoliberais e globalistas transformacionalistas. Na segunda, fazemos a distinção entre os céticos realistas e os céticos marxistas. Irei analisar os pensadores mais importantes de cada uma dessas quatro abordagens, resumindo os argumentos mais influentes que avançam para sustentar os seus pontos de vista. Ao agrupar os pontos de vista desses autores, indicarei as semelhanças e as diferenças entre as quatro perspetivas para, assim, contribuir para tornar o debate mais claro. Numa outra seção, examino criticamente esses argumentos, identificando alguns dos seus pontos fortes e fracos.
Palavras-chave
Como citar este artigo
Valentim, Vicente (2016). “The debate on the relationship between globalization, poverty and inequality: a critical overview”. JANUS.NET e-journal of International Relations, Vol. 7, Nº. 2, November 2016-April 2017. Consulted [online] on the date of last consultation, http://hdl.handle.net/11144/2783
Article received on 5 February, 2016 and accepted for publication on 19 September, 2016